Scott Kraus, a strong Call reporter and contributor to the newspaper’s Pennsylvania Ave. blog, comments on barbs traded between the Democrats and Republicans over the stimulus one year later:
How is it possible that [the GOP's] Spain and [left-leaning Keystone Research Center's] Herzenberg are living in the same country? Could the truth lie somewhere in between?
But the political rhetoric, which also seeped into the Lehigh Valley’s 15th Congressional District, shows little sign of finding what was once called “the vital center.”
This is a good example of the frustrating tendency of many journalists to assume that the truth lies somewhere in the middle. The facts might fall mid-way between the two partisans’ statements, or they very well may not. It’s the journalists’ job—and it’s a hard one—to try to sort out the truth.
Reminds me of an exchange on Jon Stewart’s Daily Show back in 2004, during the presidential race, with Stewart and correspondent Rob Corddry:
JON STEWART: Here’s what puzzles me most, Rob. John Kerry’s record in Vietnam is pretty much right there in the official records of the US military, and haven’t been disputed for 35 years?
ROB CORDDRY: That’s right, Jon, and that’s certainly the spin you’ll be hearing coming from the Kerry campaign over the next few days.
STEWART: Th-that’s not a spin thing, that’s a fact. That’s established.
CORDDRY: Exactly, Jon, and that established, incontrovertible fact is one side of the story.
STEWART: But that should be — isn’t that the end of the story? I mean, you’ve seen the records, haven’t you? What’s your opinion?
CORDDRY: I’m sorry, my *opinion*? No, I don’t have ‘o-pin-i-ons’. I’m a reporter, Jon, and my job is to spend half the time repeating what one side says, and half the time repeating the other. Little thing called ‘objectivity’ — might wanna look it up some day.
STEWART: Doesn’t objectivity mean objectively weighing the evidence, and calling out what’s credible and what isn’t?
CORDDRY: Whoa-ho! Well, well, well — sounds like someone wants the media to act as a filter! ‘Ooh, this allegation is spurious! Upon investigation this claim lacks any basis in reality! Mmm, mmm, mmm.’ Listen buddy: not my job to stand between the people talking to me and the people listening to me.